Our Mindfulness Podcast: A Critical Look at Mindfulness #Episode 1
Mindfulness podcast: in this post, we introduce the first episode of our podcast, which was originally released under the name About the Mind and is now called Tonka & Phil. If you're curious, read on and find out more about the episode!
Mindfulness podcast: In this post, we introduce the first episode of our podcast, which was originally released under the name About the Mind and is now called Tonka & Phil. If you’re curious, read on and find out more about the episode!
Mindfulness podcast – A summary of our very first episode
In this article, we will walk you through the content of the first episode of our podcast Tonka & Phil, #1 A critical look at mindfulness, with social psychologist Dr Simon Schindler.
Find out more about his views on mindfulness and his research into it from the perspective of social psychology. Simon also explains how mindfulness and science can be brought together and shares the experiences he has had as a scientist.
Overview: What is the conversation with Dr Simon Schindler about?
- What critical aspects come with mindfulness?
- What role does the intention behind mindfulness practice play?
- What influence does mindfulness have on society?
- How are science, faith and meditation connected?
- What has Dr Simon Schindler learnt from Terror Management Theory and dealing with death?
- Why do people lie, and is it possible to detect lies?
- From an evolutionary perspective, do people prefer to trust one another or to uncover lies?

Mindfulness podcast – Suppressing our own values & losing empathy?
By examining the conscience of people who took part in mindfulness exercises and comparing them with a control group who did no exercise, he found that mindfulness reduces feelings of guilt.
For example, people who practise mindfulness feel less guilty about eating meat, even when they have been informed about its impact and significance. Simon attributes these results to the fact that Western culture practises “bare mindfulness” – a form of mindfulness that, unlike its original Buddhist form, is completely detached from any foundation of values.
Simon explains that this is a simple breathing exercise that helps practitioners adopt an observer’s perspective and thus gain a more objective view. Mindfulness should therefore be approached with some caution: it does not lead directly to more empathy, nor is it the solution to every problem. If you want to focus on developing more kindness and empathy, metta meditation would be far better suited.
When many other mindfulness experts heard about his critical view of mindfulness at an MBSR conference, he received a very positive response despite his contrary stance. He found it especially interesting to be shown other perspectives on mindfulness and feelings of guilt.
Mindfulness podcast – Nuances of mindfulness in our society
When it comes to society, Simon is in favour of practising mindfulness, especially in times of social media and digitalisation. He sees mindfulness as an opportunity to create your own space, but also to understand other points of view.
However, he also sees a danger in the mindfulness trend. This trend could lead to people being expected to adapt even more to the system, rather than the system adapting to people.
He considers it extremely difficult to say whether and how the system can be changed for the better, since a certain amount of suffering would first be needed for behaviour and the system to change.

Mindfulness podcast – The problem with science, faith & meditation
Looking at his own development with regard to meditation, Simon explains that his research has made it harder for him to fully engage with meditation. Because of the criticism he has received from other advocates of mindfulness, he struggles with precisely this and feels as though he is betraying mindfulness.
He adds that, as a scientist, he finds it hard to accept it fully. According to Simon, science also makes it harder to believe in a god. For mindfulness and Zen Buddhism, on the other hand, there is empirical evidence of their effectiveness, which is why Simon can be more open towards them.
The conversation then moves on to Terror Management Theory, in which Simon explores fascinating questions about death and how we deal with the awareness of our own mortality.
He also answers questions about lying, a subject he has researched extensively: what is the difference between white lies, told out of politeness, and lies told purely out of self-interest? Are there tricks for spotting lies?
Dr Simon Schindler addresses these and many other thought-provoking questions in the very first episode of our podcast, where you can dive deep and learn more about his insights.
Tonka & Phil: Your inspiring psychology podcast
Tonka & Phil: Our podcast delves into people’s minds. As psychologists, we care deeply about topics relating to the psyche and mental health. These focus above all on mental training, but also include neuroscience, research, sleep, transhumanism, innovation and many other fascinating aspects.
That is why we have made it our mission to learn more about them and share it with you. To do this, we invite experts from a wide range of fields to find out more about their work and knowledge. In our conversations, guests are also given space to share their biggest lessons and challenges with us and, of course, with you. These encounters move us – and we learn that there is still a great deal we don’t know and that we want to keep striving for more.

Find out more about Dr Simon Schindler here:
- Does mindfulness make us selfish, Mr Schindler?
- Does mindfulness make us immune to a guilty conscience?
- Achtsamkeit – Wirksame Medizin ohne Nebenwirkung?
- New study on mindfulness: the side effects of inner calm
Meditation: a personal experience
If you’d like to explore mindfulness and meditation further, we have an interesting post for you here! See you there!
Deepen your meditation practice with Mindfulife
Meditation can be more than a short break in your everyday life. If you would like to understand more deeply how meditation works, how to build a steady practice of your own and how to guide others mindfully, our meditation teacher training is the next step. There you will not only get to know meditation in theory, but also develop more confidence, clarity and trust in your own practice.
Would you like to find out more about the training first? In our weekly webinar you will get an insight and learn more about what your path to becoming a meditation teacher could look like.
For regular support in your everyday life, you can also use our online meditation studio and join guided meditations flexibly via Eversports.
We look forward to accompanying you on your journey.


